A working B2B cold email program replies at 2% to 6% of delivered emails in 2026, with a third to a half of those positive. Below 1% means a deliverability or list problem. The levers, in order: list fit, offer, deliverability, copy.
The numbers
| Metric | Weak | Working | Strong |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reply rate (delivered) | under 1% | 2 to 4% | 5%+ |
| Positive share of replies | under 20% | 30 to 50% | 50%+ |
| Positive to meeting | under 40% | 60% | 75%+ |
| Bounce rate | over 5% | under 2% | under 1% |
Why reply rate, not open rate
Open tracking requires a pixel, which hurts placement, and Apple's mail privacy fires it whether or not anyone looked. Replies are the only honest measure. Count negative replies too; they prove the email was read.
The levers
- List fit. The right 200 people beat the wrong 2,000. Most low reply rates are targeting problems.
- Offer. A specific outcome for their situation, not a product description.
- Deliverability. If you are not in the inbox, nothing else matters. See the diagnosis.
- Copy. Last, and smallest. Shorter and more specific almost always wins.
Model your own funnel in the ROI calculator.
Cold email ROI calculator
Turn send volume and reply rates into meetings, deals, revenue and cost per meeting.
Open the toolTurn send volume and reply rates into meetings, deals, revenue and cost per meeting.
Questions
What is a good cold email open rate?
Open rate is no longer reliable because of privacy proxies and tracking pixels. Measure replies.
Why do I get replies but no meetings?
Either the replies are polite declines, which means the offer is off, or the follow-up to positive replies is slow. Reply within an hour during business hours.